This was Ethan's third real Halloween, since he was only 5 months
old in 2006. His first year we dressed him up as a rockstar and went
out with one of Benjamin's cousins from around the corner. He loved
walking up to people's houses, but as often as not he put candy from his
bag into their bowls, and showed no interest in actually eating any of
it.
His second year, he wore a lion costume and went out with his
best friend from daycare, a monkey, and they vacuumed up candy around
our apartment complex, a Halloween kids mecca. He and S ran boldly up
to every door until someone opened it up dressed as a ghost and
silently extended a long, pointy ghost finger at them both. The managed
to work through their fear for two more houses, but the jig was up. It took us longer that year to gradually throw away most of the candy, so he got to eat quite a few pieces before it disappeared.
This
year he had picked out Tigger costumes for both himself and Austin, but
as it turned out the pictures I took the day we bought them are the
only shots we have of them both dressed up. Ethan refused to dress up while he helped Phil hand out
candy for a while, pushing his hand through the spider webs and jack
o'lanterns decorating our door. Only when Phil started to walk next door with Austin as Tigger (babies are so cooperative!) did Ethan consent to put his Tigger pants on and venture out for candy. We handed out most of the rest of our candy and called it a night.
It felt a bit anti-climactic after all was said and done. What makes our complex fun for Halloween - the sheer density of kids and candy-giving households - also takes away some of the drama of the night. Our old neighborhood had those dark spaces between houses, where you can imagine all kinds of spookiness, wonder whether the next house will be dark, candlelit, or haunted.
Last year, the light and activity where we live were perfect for two-year-old boys still at sea in the very idea of Halloween. But now, I think Ethan is old enough to dwell in that space of fear, excitement, dread and adrenaline that make Halloween what it is. His current fascination with aging, scarecrows, and death is the very kind of intense grappling with what it means to be alive and human that is the driving spirit behind Halloween.
I think next year we will return to our old neighborhood and its pockets of darkness and mystery, maybe even I can recapture the excitement I remember from my childhood, faces sweating in our masks, even in freezing Minnesota, as we explored a neighborhood rendered unfamiliar for a night, never knowing what might greet us at the next door.